For Sale1 / 57

5 bd · 6 ba · 3,765 sqft

$2,285,000

5536 Easterly Road, Agoura Hills, CA 91301

Est. $10,960/moFor Sale · 101 days on market · MLS# 226003850

Overview

Bedrooms5
Bathrooms6
Living area3,765 sqft
Price / sqft$607/sqft
Home typeHouse
Year built1989
Lot size18,415 sqft
On market101 days

A rare Old Agoura retreat where relaxed California living meets exceptional space and versatility. Tucked beneath a canopy of mature trees and privately gated, this 5-bedroom, 6-bath residence spans more than 3,700 square feet and offers 3 wood burning fireplaces and an uncommon 4-car garage. This unique property features two parcels totally 21,473 SqFt. Dramatic ceilings and oversized windows fill the interiors with natural light, while an inviting fireplace, rich wood floors and an open-concept kitchen create an effortless setting for gathering. A built-in dining nook wrapped in windows adds warmth and character while overlooking the lush surroundings.Outside, the property unfolds into a private entertainer's escape with a swimming pool and spa, multiple conversation and dining opportunities, mature landscaping and a striking oversized fountain. Whether enjoying a sunny afternoon by the pool or dinner beneath the trees, the grounds capture the laid-back charm for which Old Agoura is known.Perhaps most compelling is the inclusion of a second parcel, creating intriguing possibilities for a future ADU. Conveniently positioned just moments from the high school and two expansive neighborhood parks, this special property combines location, lifestyle and opportunity in one remarkable offering.

AI insights

✦ Property conditionReady to move inBuilt in 1989
✦ Top attributeUnique Lifestyle and Entertainment Value
Read the full report
Unique Lifestyle and Entertainment Value

This property offers a rare blend of relaxed California living, expansive indoor and outdoor spaces, and exceptional versatility, creating a unique value proposition for buyers seeking a luxurious retreat with endless entertainment possibilities.

Future Development and Investment Potential

The inclusion of a second parcel and the potential for a future ADU create a compelling opportunity for buyers looking to invest in a property with long-term development potential, offering a unique combination of current lifestyle benefits and future investment returns.

✦ Price vs. city average$8/sqft above city average
✦ Cost of ownershipHigh cost

This property's high cost is driven by its large size, premium features such as a private gated entrance, 4-car garage, and high-end finishes, as well as its desirable location in Agoura Hills, which will result in higher maintenance, utility, insurance, and property tax costs.

Opportunity

Enhancement opportunity i
Low opportunity
Lot utilization i
20%
Estimated rent
$10,935/mo
ADU eligible
No

Cost & risk

$10,960per month, estimated
  • Principal & interest$10,960
  • Down payment (20%)$457,000
Adjust down payment, rate and term

Excludes property tax and insurance. An estimate, not a loan offer.

Climate insurance risk i
High

Features

Interior & amenities

✦ Grade B

The property's construction, featuring a tile roof, forced air and natural gas heating, and central air and zoned cooling, meets market standards, but its 37-year age and low renovation potential suggest a moderate level of value creation.

Roof condition i
A
Roof
Tile
Flooring
Wood
Interior
Cathedral Ceilings, Dry Bar, Separate Formal Dining Room, Eat In Kitchen, Walk In Closets
Laundry
Inside, Laundry Room, Upper Level
Fireplace
Insert, Family Room, Gas, Gas Starter, Living Room, Primary Bedroom, Wood Burning Stove
Appliances
Double Oven, Dishwasher, Disposal, Refrigerator, Range Hood
Pool
Gas Heat, Heated, In Ground, Waterfall
Spa
In Ground
Lot
Irregular Lot, Sprinkler System, Yard

Structure & style

✦ Grade A

The property's unique blend of relaxed California living, dramatic ceilings, oversized windows, and rich wood floors creates an exceptional value proposition, significantly exceeding market norms with its effortless setting for gathering and private entertainer's escape.

Architectural style
Spanish
Stories
2
Levels
Two
Full baths
3
Half baths
2
Garage spaces
4
Total parking
4
Construction
Plaster
Fencing
Wrought Iron
Zoning
AHRA2OOOO*

Utilities & HOA

✦ Grade B

The property's utility modernity and completeness are notable, with features like a gas-heated pool and appliances included, but its utility efficiency is only moderate, resulting in a moderate level of value creation that meets market standards.

Utilities modernity i
B
Utilities completeness i
A
Utilities efficiency i
B
Cooling
Central Air, Zoned
Heating
Forced Air, Natural Gas

Schools & safety

Violent crimeVery Low1 per 1,000 residents
Property crimeLower14.9 per 1,000 residents
Air qualityAQI 34 · Good
Pollutant levels
Fine particulate matter (PM2.5)
Below average 8.09 µg/m³
Particulate matter (PM10)
Below average 20.37 µg/m³
Ozone
Below average 52.41 ppb
Nitrogen dioxide
Below average 6.49 ppb
Carbon monoxide
Below average 0.26 ppm
Sulfur dioxide
Below average 0.44 ppb
Black carbon
Below average 0.47 µg/m³
Combustion organic aerosol
Below average 0.37 µg/m³
Hydrocarbon-like organic aerosol
Below average 0.22 µg/m³
Particle number concentration
Below average 7213.76 particles/cm³

Nearest public schools

Elementary
Willow Elementary · 0.9 mi
Middle
Medea Creek Middle · 2.5 mi
High
Agoura High · 0.1 mi

Crime: FBI. Air quality: CACES. Schools: California Open Data. Check school assignment with the district.

Listing courtesy of Compass. Listing provided by Deborah Kernahan (DRE# 00909823). MLS# 226003850, CRMLS. Listed 2026-08-12. Last updated September 22, 2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
GS