For Sale1 / 48

4 bd · 4 ba · 2,873 sqft

$1,900,000

5631 Foothill Drive, Agoura Hills, CA 91301

Est. $9,113/moFor Sale · 78 days on market · MLS# 226004217

Overview

Bedrooms4
Bathrooms4
Living area2,873 sqft
Price / sqft$661/sqft
Year built1964
Lot size85,035 sqft
On market78 days

One of Old Agoura's truly exceptional properties, this nearly 2-acre, fully usable and remarkably flat parcel offers a rare opportunity to create an estate of your own in one of the Conejo Valley's most distinctive communities. With two existing homes, on-site utilities, and dual addresses already in place, the possibilities are extensive: move in and enjoy the property as it is, expand the existing residences, create a private family compound, or bring your vision for a custom estate to life.Nestled within the natural beauty of the Santa Monica Mountains, the property is conveniently located by the trail system leading into Cheeseboro and Palo Comado Canyons, where approximately 4,000 acres of scenic open space offer miles of trails for hiking, horseback riding, and cycling. Sweeping views of Ladyface Mountain create an extraordinary backdrop, while the expansive grounds provide ample room to envision your own equestrian amenities, gardens, pool, guest accommodations, or additional outdoor living spaces. With an optional HOA and no high fees or restrictive rules, Old Agoura offers a rare sense of freedom and space that feels wonderfully removed from the ordinary.The possibilities extend even further with the adjacent approximately 0.63-acre parcel, which may also be available, offering a potential opportunity to combine the properties for a total of approximately 2.58 acres. . Whether pursuing a larger estate, exploring a lot split or merger, adding an ADU, or simply preserving the expansive grounds, this is a property that offers both immediate lifestyle appeal and exceptional long-term potential.And yet, despite its peaceful, country-like setting, convenience is never compromised. Old Agoura is cherished for its equestrian character, wide-open spaces, neighborhood park and riding arena, and access to some of the area's most beloved riding and hiking trails. Acclaimed Las Virgenes Unified School District schools, prestigious private schools, shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences are all nearby, with easy access to the 101 freeway and Malibu's beaches just approximately 20 minutes away.Opportunities of this scale, setting, and versatility are extraordinarily rare in Old Agoura. For those seeking space, privacy, natural beauty, and the freedom to create something truly exceptional, this is more than a home or a piece of land. This is the ultimate opportunity to shape an extraordinary way of life in one of Southern California's most coveted communities.

AI insights

✦ Property conditionReady to move inBuilt in 1964
✦ Top attributeUnique Land Development Opportunities
Read the full report
Unique Land Development Opportunities

This property offers a rare chance to create a custom estate or family compound in a highly sought-after area, with its nearly 2-acre, flat parcel and existing infrastructure, including on-site utilities and dual addresses, providing extensive possibilities for expansion, renovation, or redevelopment.

Long-Term Appreciation and Rental Income Potential

This property's location in the prestigious Las Virgenes Unified School District, its proximity to scenic open spaces, and its potential for expansion or redevelopment position it for long-term appreciation in value, while its estimated monthly rental income of $8,700 provides a significant potential revenue stream for investors.

✦ Price vs. city average$78/sqft above city average
✦ Cost of ownershipHigh cost

The property's large lot size, potential for equestrian amenities, and high-end finishes contribute to its high cost of ownership, while its age and potential for renovation or expansion may also lead to significant upkeep and maintenance expenses.

Opportunity

Enhancement opportunity i
Potential to add ADU (verify zoning); Expand living area
Lot utilization i
3%
Estimated rent
$8,671/mo
ADU eligible
Yes, but verify zoning category

Cost & risk

$9,113per month, estimated
  • Principal & interest$9,113
  • Down payment (20%)$380,000
Adjust down payment, rate and term

Excludes property tax and insurance. An estimate, not a loan offer.

Climate insurance risk i
High

Features

Interior & amenities

✦ Grade B

The property's existing homes, built in 1964, and on-site utilities meet market standards, but the age and condition of the properties may require updates or renovations to reach their full potential.

Flooring
Wood
Interior
Country Kitchen
Laundry
Inside
Appliances
Dishwasher, Gas Cooking, Refrigerator
View
Mountains
Lot
Back Yard, Horse Property, Rectangular Lot, Ranch, Walkstreet, Yard

Structure & style

✦ Grade A

The property's exceptional design and architectural features, including its expansive grounds, sweeping views of Ladyface Mountain, and potential for equestrian amenities, create a unique and valuable living space that significantly exceeds market norms.

Architectural style
Custom
Stories
1
Levels
One
Full baths
4
Garage spaces
4
Parking
Covered, Garage, Gated, Oversized, Rv Access Parking
Total parking
4
Common walls
No Common Walls
Fencing
Wood, Wrought Iron
Zoning
AHRA20000*

Utilities & HOA

✦ Grade B

The property has on-site utilities, including dual addresses, but the utility modernity is rated as 'C' and the utility efficiency is unknown, indicating potential areas for improvement to meet modern standards and expectations.

Utilities modernity i
C
Utilities completeness i
B
Community
Rural

Schools & safety

Violent crimeVery Low1 per 1,000 residents
Property crimeLower14.9 per 1,000 residents
Air qualityAQI 34 · Good
Pollutant levels
Fine particulate matter (PM2.5)
Below average 8.09 µg/m³
Particulate matter (PM10)
Below average 20.37 µg/m³
Ozone
Below average 52.41 ppb
Nitrogen dioxide
Below average 6.49 ppb
Carbon monoxide
Below average 0.26 ppm
Sulfur dioxide
Below average 0.44 ppb
Black carbon
Below average 0.47 µg/m³
Combustion organic aerosol
Below average 0.37 µg/m³
Hydrocarbon-like organic aerosol
Below average 0.22 µg/m³
Particle number concentration
Below average 7213.76 particles/cm³

Nearest public schools

Elementary
Willow Elementary · 0.9 mi
Middle
Medea Creek Middle · 2.5 mi
High
Agoura High · 0.1 mi

Crime: FBI. Air quality: CACES. Schools: California Open Data. Check school assignment with the district.

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Westlake Village. Listing provided by Jennifer Sommer-Tarbet (DRE# 02440581); co-listed by Stephanie Gavin, Keller Williams Westlake Village. MLS# 226004217, CRMLS. Listed 2026-09-04. Last updated October 23, 2026. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
GS